I’m sure this is going to get me flamed by some of my more geeky friends and it’ll probably get me labeled even more as a Mac fanboy (there are worse things I could be called) but I just don’t get Linux, I’ve been playing around with a few different distributions and well…I’m not impressed. In fact, I just don’t get the devotion that Linux people have, every distribution that I played with had one thing in common, they just didn’t feel complete.
The last one (and last one for me for a pretty long while) was ubuntu on its homepage it touts that “You’ll never go back”, it is supposed to be the super easy “every persons” Linux distro. Apparently I’m just not geeky enough for it because, while I appreciate the fact that it is free and includes many free open-source applications, it just feels empty, uncompleted.
Now, this is coming from a Mac person, so if you’ve never used a Mac you should understand one thing…people are passionate about the Mac for good reason, it works the way a computer should work, you want to uninstall something you drag it to the trash can, sure you can get really geeky with it but it is made not to frustrate the user but to enhance the overall computing experience. It has a lot of quality free software out for it, Linux has a lot of free software.
My opinion of Linux is that it is bland, kind of like going fishing, cleaning your catch, and then boiling it…sure it will feed and nourish you but it isn’t something that you are going to get excited about.
I’ve got plenty of friends who enjoy command line and tweaking there own personal Linux distro (something you can’t do with OS X or Windows) and I really wanted to enjoy using Linux, I hoped with all of the different flavors that I’d find one, I even saved ubuntu for last because it predicted that I’d never go back, I mean that is a bold claim, I was nervous about trying to explain to my wife why I turned my beloved Macbook into this lean mean white Linux machine and that scared me…but luckily I didn’t have to do that. I’ll leave it installed as a virtual machine under VMware in case I get the urge again but I’m thinking it’ll just get deleted in the not to distant future.
Linux people, I salute you, takes a rare breed to enjoy that. I understand that I’m selling out to the man and that I’ll never “know” the freedom that you enjoy but it is a sacrifice I’m willing to make.
Entry by Chris




Richard Chapman 9:46 am on April 29, 2008 Permalink |
You’re absolutely right. Linux is incomplete and you don’t get it. That’s ok. You see, the missing piece in Linux is you. The user is the keystone and that will never change. That doesn’t mean Linux is or will always be a geek’s toy. It just means the user is expected to make the Linux installation his own. I don’t usually tell people this but you should avoid Linux. You will not be happy with it. Linux works for people who have never used a computer before (yes, that’s right) or feel compelled to use it by the environment created by proprietary interests. Some people are also attracted to it for its technical superiority and openness. The ones who should avoid Linux would be like the art student who, upon given his one-square-foot cube of clay, declared his sculpture finished.
Chris 3:15 pm on April 29, 2008 Permalink |
Nice reply Richard, I think that my way of thinking about Linux should adapt to what Linux is, see I always thought that what you got is what you worked with but if I look at the way that you described and that it is opened for complete end user adaptation than I think I’ll keep playing around with it…
As for my end of term art project…well, the cube was there to be what anyone wanted, who am I to determine what that cube of clay should be, I am just a man.
fan 4:43 am on June 3, 2008 Permalink |
Fan says : I absolutely agree with this !